Close

  • RIPP vs. Magnuson...SuperCharger Shootout!

    You knew it was coming. Its finally here. We are going to turn these to SuperCharger heavy weights loose against one another in a battery of tests. Lets get to know the competitors.



    Reigning Champ - Black Betty. She's and internet celebrity, been on the cutting edge of prototype gear for the last 2 years. She'll be representing RIPP SuperChargers in this all out throw down. She is a Rubicon Unlimited with 4.10 gearing and for the purposes of these tests, she will shed her 37'' KM2s in favor of BFG Kms 255/75r17. (stock Rubi tires)



    The Challenger - Sweet Pea / Pea Soup'd. Yes she's got two names, one from us, and the other from one of our readers. She's essentially brand new. 2013 JKUR all stock everything....Except her Magnuson SuperCharger.



    Whats the difference? Two routes to the same end. MORE POWER. its widely known that there is really no way to add punch to your JEEP JK without taking drastic measures. We have done the dyno testing on intakes and exhausts. The sound changes, but not much else. If you really want to unleash the beast that is your pentastar JK motor, we are paving the road for you.
    This article was originally published in forum thread: RIPP vs. Magnuson...SuperCharger Shootout! started by JeepLab View original post
    Comments 243 Comments
    1. Rexx19's Avatar
      Rexx19 -
      im a fan of a custom tune. JL's BB tune is pretty much custom as Betty was the 6 speed prototype truck for them. So her tune is not a plug in. Its ripp tuning her perfectly, then sending Betty's tune to the other buyer so the ripp kit.

      Pretty cool that people all over the US are driving trucks based on the tuning of Black Betty.
    1. JeepLab's Avatar
      JeepLab -
      Quote Originally Posted by Rexx19 View Post
      im a fan of a custom tune. JL's BB tune is pretty much custom as Betty was the 6 speed prototype truck for them. So her tune is not a plug in. Its ripp tuning her perfectly, then sending Betty's tune to the other buyer so the ripp kit.

      Pretty cool that people all over the US are driving trucks based on the tuning of Black Betty.
      BB was the prototype for the manual trans '12 Ripp kit, But I'm not sure that the current tune is built off her cpu. She has been back to RIPP a few times, and they have released new tunes after, but I think Ripp has a few test trucks now, Im not sure if they are all 12s. Betty was the first Manual trans, but I don't think she is currently the only one.
    1. Pznivy's Avatar
      Pznivy -
      Whats up with the hi alt kits? Deola just put his in, Is JL's SC's upgraded?
    1. JeepLab's Avatar
      JeepLab -
      We have the parts, but I havent had my hands on sweet pea in weeks, and Betty has been getting her coilovers reworked.

      We are getting around to it. Might even dyno the new pulleys for comparison.
    1. Timmy's Avatar
      Timmy -
      Quote Originally Posted by JeepLab View Post
      We have the parts, but I havent had my hands on sweet pea in weeks, and Betty has been getting her coilovers reworked.

      We are getting around to it. Might even dyno the new pulleys for comparison.
      Oh, yes, yes, please dyno!!!

      Did you ever find out, do the SC makers really support using High Elevation pully's at sea level? How much extra psi do you expect out of the high elevation pully's? I thought I remember that standard you were getting around 8 psi, correct?
    1. gbaumann's Avatar
      gbaumann -
      Quote Originally Posted by JeepLab View Post
      Cheap enough to consider, but really, the tune from the the manufacturer should sort out issues like surging.

      Your shop is probably pretty good. I wouldnt leave the truck with just anyone promising to tune it.

      Anyone reading this, check your shop's references.
      I agree that 650 is a reasonable price for a custom tune if it will really solve issues we users are having. That said, where does one go to find a good tuner and check their references? I'd even be willing to share a custom tune file with the supercharger manufacturer so they can compare to the tunes they are putting out. Perhaps the feedback might help others. We've been patiently waiting for manufacturers to set up test truck and try to replicate customer issues but it's taking quite a while.
    1. 2k13jk's Avatar
      2k13jk -
      Based on what my tuner has told me and from my data logging on my computer the surging people are experiencing near 2k rpm is the engine running very lean for about a second and picks back up also when WOT the air fuel was running extremely rich. For new people to boost a desired number cruising is 14.7 for air fuel anything above is lean and below that number is rich. My tuner told me that ideal air fuel when WOT full boost should be around 11.1 i was running 8.3 and was losing gas out the tail pipe and lost power running that rich. He tuned it and it runs just like a normal factory truck. Ripp did a well job dialing a in box tune so you can drive it all day everyday but i suggest just getting it dialed in spend the money know your engine is running proper i beleive no truck is the same and will run slightly different depending on conditions
    1. JeepLab's Avatar
      JeepLab -
      Quote Originally Posted by 2k13jk View Post
      Based on what my tuner has told me and from my data logging on my computer the surging people are experiencing near 2k rpm is the engine running very lean for about a second and picks back up also when WOT the air fuel was running extremely rich. For new people to boost a desired number cruising is 14.7 for air fuel anything above is lean and below that number is rich. My tuner told me that ideal air fuel when WOT full boost should be around 11.1 i was running 8.3 and was losing gas out the tail pipe and lost power running that rich. He tuned it and it runs just like a normal factory truck. Ripp did a well job dialing a in box tune so you can drive it all day everyday but i suggest just getting it dialed in spend the money know your engine is running proper i beleive no truck is the same and will run slightly different depending on conditions
      good info!
    1. 2k13jk's Avatar
      2k13jk -
      Quote Originally Posted by JeepLab View Post
      good info!
      So final dyno numbers are in from my custom tune ripps tune made 250 wheel on the dyno running extremely rich now with my new tune i made 344 wheel
    1. JeepLab's Avatar
      JeepLab -
      Quote Originally Posted by 2k13jk View Post
      So final dyno numbers are in from my custom tune ripps tune made 250 wheel on the dyno running extremely rich now with my new tune i made 344 wheel
      standard pulley or high alt?
    1. 2k13jk's Avatar
      2k13jk -
      Quote Originally Posted by JeepLab View Post
      standard pulley or high alt?
      That was with the standard pulley running 8lbs of boost
    1. JeepLab's Avatar
      JeepLab -
      Quote Originally Posted by 2k13jk View Post
      That was with the standard pulley running 8lbs of boost
      Do you have a chart?

      I got 328 (I think) 4.10 gearing, 6spd, 32" tires, Did you have all the same set up?
    1. 2k13jk's Avatar
      2k13jk -
      Quote Originally Posted by JeepLab View Post
      Do you have a chart?

      I got 328 (I think) 4.10 gearing, 6spd, 32" tires, Did you have all the same set up?
      Im running 35s 6 speed 3.21 gears i have the chart but idk how to upload it
    1. BigPrince's Avatar
      BigPrince -
      As a new JK owner looking to figure out which direction to go I just wanted to say thanks for sharing your experiences.
    1. JeepLab's Avatar
      JeepLab -
      Quote Originally Posted by BigPrince View Post
      As a new JK owner looking to figure out which direction to go I just wanted to say thanks for sharing your experiences.
      How did I miss the first post? Did this guy just skip to post 2?

      WELCOME PRINCE!
    1. Timmy's Avatar
      Timmy -
      Quote Originally Posted by 2k13jk View Post
      Im running 35s 6 speed 3.21 gears i have the chart but idk how to upload it
      Really, you are running 3.21 gearing and you got 344 whp? That is awesome. So tell me, how does it drive with your setup? If my finances line up, I'm on the edge of a getting a Magnuson SC, and upgrading to 37" tires (I'm at 35" now.) I imagine 37" tires with my 3.73 ratio will be similar to your 35" tires with the 3.21 ratio, so I'm curious if you feel you need to re-gear (given that we are both manual transmissions, so we can just down shift to a lower gear when needed.)

      I wish I could pull the trigger on these items right now, but lately my money has been getting sucked away with family needs. It's amazing how expensive braces are these days for kids! I mean, that's a set of tires right there! Both of them, and that is a supercharger! I'm going to remind them of that when they are older, A LOT. "You like those straight teeth? I hope you do, because your teeth cost me my upgrades on my Jeep. You know how much fun we would have had doing burn-outs and cruisin' around on 37" tires? I hope you appreciate what was sacrificed so you could have straight teeth."
    1. Yoinkers's Avatar
      Yoinkers -
      It seems that the higher axle gear (lower number) makes more power on the dyno.

      2k13jk making more than black betty using the factors of larger tires, 32 vs 35, and higher gearing 3.21 vs 4.10 makes the hp numbers climb.... Or so the prodigy thread says.

      That seemed to be the reason that Jesse's Girl with a turbo and 4.88s made less power than expected.

      SOOOOO many variables with these dynos.
    1. ferrarifast's Avatar
      ferrarifast -
      Hello everyone! I have been stressing for the past week over what SC to buy.. I live in Utah at 4400 ft. above sea level and on occasion pull a two place Harley trailer or a 20' Ski boat over mountain passes (7000-8000 Ft). They are quoting me 10K for the Maggie (High Altitude Version) with Diablo tuner and a PLX multi gauge to monitor boost, AFR, O2 Sensor, knock and alarms. The price includes before and after Dyno testing and four hours of tuning. My quote for the Ripp SC is 8K for the system, install, tuning and Dyno. Is the extra gauges unnecessary and redundant? What is best for my application as described? Any input is greatly appreciated. System is going on a 2012 four door JK, running 35's with a 4 inch teraflex lift and 4.88 gears, automatic tranny, with Ram Air Intake and Magna flow exhaust.
    1. Yoinkers's Avatar
      Yoinkers -
      WELCOME!

      Quote Originally Posted by ferrarifast View Post
      Hello everyone! I have been stressing for the past week over what SC to buy.. I live in Utah at 4400 ft. above sea level and on occasion pull a two place Harley trailer or a 20' Ski boat over mountain passes (7000-8000 Ft). They are quoting me 10K for the Maggie (High Altitude Version) with Diablo tuner and a PLX multi gauge to monitor boost, AFR, O2 Sensor, knock and alarms. The price includes before and after Dyno testing and four hours of tuning. My quote for the Ripp SC is 8K for the system, install, tuning and Dyno. Is the extra gauges unnecessary and redundant? What is best for my application as described? Any input is greatly appreciated. System is going on a 2012 four door JK, running 35's with a 4 inch teraflex lift and 4.88 gears, automatic tranny, with Ram Air Intake and Magna flow exhaust.
      Im sure JL will weigh in, but in these cases, where we are talking towing i think you want the most low end you can get. The Magnuson may be worth its price here. BUT.... have they figured out their tune?

      Manual trans or auto?
    1. ferrarifast's Avatar
      ferrarifast -
      Quote Originally Posted by Yoinkers View Post
      WELCOME!



      Im sure JL will weigh in, but in these cases, where we are talking towing i think you want the most low end you can get. The Magnuson may be worth its price here. BUT.... have they figured out their tune?

      Manual trans or auto?
      Automatic transmission
    Untitled Document