Takin the PLUNGE!!

[HahaJK]

I think it comes down to your drive style. like a little lower end? but still want the power modulated by the gas pedal? go magnuson, if you like more power further up the rpm band, that just keeps going? Ripp. Strong power line that is less under control, then the prodigy turbo.
.

Based on that, how would you expand on it - if you were to write a more specific description of the driver for say..

RIPP
Magnuson
Edelbrock
Prodigy.

I'm looking at these myself. I like the idea of RIPP with a high altitude pulley - the numbers are good, it's not exhaust dependent, and the graph starts off great. But I'm always so drawn back to prodigy because their pushing a significant amount of power more than the superchargers, but the lag time worries me and building boost.

Then again, my rig is primarily a trail rig. River crossings, steep climbs, and mud.

[JeepLab]

Based on that, how would you expand on it - if you were to write a more specific description of the driver for say..

RIPP
Magnuson
Edelbrock
Prodigy.

I'm looking at these myself. I like the idea of RIPP with a high altitude pulley - the numbers are good, it's not exhaust dependent, and the graph starts off great. But I'm always so drawn back to prodigy because their pushing a significant amount of power more than the superchargers, but the lag time worries me and building boost.

Then again, my rig is primarily a trail rig. River crossings, steep climbs, and mud.

If your truck is pimarily a triail rig ^^, Id say go with the one of the SC's. The turbo shines on the highway. and it does SHINE. But in the rocks, i'd personally prefer a supercharger to turbo.

That being said, Of the Superchargers, You have to decide based on preference.

RIPP will crank out more power in acute wheeling situations. Meaning if you are against a rock and want climb it, Id take the spool up of the RIPP to 4500RPM you can get more high end power in the lowest gear and turn your jeep into a torque monster.

Mag and edelbrock will be in the same ballpark, but will be more susceptible to heat at low speeds, and baking in the desert sun.

The downside to RIPP is water. I personally would avoid water that is as high as the intake. Even with a snorkel. People think snorkels make jeeps into submarines, they don't. They are for dust. Not water. And if the seal of the snorkel isn't perfect, you have no snorkel at all.

If you looooooove snorkels, then mag would be my next choice as you can run any snorkel with it.